In 1996, I got a bartending job at the only gay bar in Fort Collins. It was a cursed bar, haunted by ghosts, a tragic past, and The Twilight Zone pinball machine. I was twenty-three that summer, in the closet, a recent college graduate with an English degree, working full-time at the local bookstore and living upstairs at my mom’s house.
I had a tragically brief romance with the manager of the local dinner theater, an older man named Tony who played the lead in the production of Anything Goes; when he sang “You’re the Top,” I imagined that he sang it directly to me in the audience. He had a beautiful tenor voice with just a hint of raspiness. He had dark hair and freckles on his shoulders, which I loved. Introduced by a mutual friend, I met Tony at a popular pizza joint after my shift at the bookstore. We were holding hands under the table by the end of the night. It was sheer luck--destiny, I thought; I didn’t have many gay friends and I felt buried alive in the closet.
As I fell in love with Tony, I started to feel like I had really conquered the closet at last. But I was desperate and needy for reassurance, which was typical for a young man emerging from the closet, and I smothered him.
With some of Tony’s friends, we took a trip to a nightclub in Denver where they pumped waves of slippery foam into the dance floor. The patrons shed their clothes and danced in the foam pit, but I couldn’t join them because I was so reserved and shy, and I was the designated driver, having borrowed my mom’s car for the night. Tony got drunk and left me at the edge of the foam pit until closing time.
I drove everyone home, but Tony was drunk and distant. He wouldn’t return my calls for days after that.
My need for constant reassurance was a pit.
It was over. I was devastated; I had to do something or else get sucked back into the closet, which felt like crawling back into a grave.
So I applied to work at the only gay bar in Fort Collins: Nightingale's. I told Tony that I applied, and Tony put in a good word for me with the owner. But Tony warned me. He thought I was too green, too fresh out of the closet.
Next to Putt-Putt Golf on the highway, across from the only strip club in town, Nightingale's was a scary bar, especially when empty in the afternoon as I prepared for Happy Hour alone. The dance floor itself was cavernous, lined with tables on the perimeter. It didn't have any windows, and there were many empty back rooms, sections closed off and filled with spare equipment and furniture, and the back hallways had red-carpeted walls. It had a terrible mice infestation; sometimes I found their little bodies in the cupboard.
It was a cursed bar.
It was Matthew Shepard’s bar. On busy Saturday nights, Matthew came down from Wyoming to dance. I remember him. He wasn’t old enough to drink yet when I worked there, but minors could come in to dance as long as they wore wristbands. They even mention Nightingale’s in The Laramie Project, the play about Shepard’s murder.
And it had a cursed history.
The original Nightingale’s burned down one Christmas season in the '80s when the bar was full on a busy Saturday night. At least two people died from asphyxiation in the bathroom. The flames made it impossible to escape. Closeted married men, the rumor went. The fire started when an angry lesbian threw matches at the dried-out Christmas tree in the bar. She had to serve a brief prison sentence. The regulars during Happy Hour told me all about it.
In 1996, the gay community was just emerging from the worst of the AIDS epidemic. I know I felt the fear of it every day, and it cast a dark shadow on my coming out.
I didn't know how to enter gay culture without a mentor. With Tony out of the picture, the only thing I could think to do was dive in. Working at a busy gay nightclub was definitely diving in. However, the bar--the literal bar where I set down the drinks--became like a barrier for me, my own personal ramparts to separate myself from the customers and from my purpose. I didn't know how to be on the other side of the bar where the people danced and socialized and hooked up.
One of the regulars for Happy Hour, a man who ordered many pitchers of Bud Light and played the trivia video game all afternoon, told me that the bar was haunted, and suddenly everything made sense. I had felt such an overwhelming sensation of dread on so many afternoons. I always assumed that this anxiety stemmed from my own struggle with the closet, but could it be a ghost?
Once, when the bar was crowded and busy, I heard a strange cascade of voices call my name like an echo throughout the bar.
The DJ for the bar seemed to be the most sensitive to the presence of the ghost. She called it "Mr. Thing," and she said when she saw it on the dance floor, the ghost looked like a moving shadow. And I did see a running shadow one afternoon next to The Twilight Zone pinball machine.

The Twilight Zone pinball machine, released in 1993 by Midway, was highly regarded among pinball aficionados. An incredible game to play, it was extremely complex and difficult, layered with references to a wide variety of Twilight Zone episodes, prominently featuring the central and iconic image of Rod Serling himself. Serling's voice, portrayed by an actor, could be heard at times along with creepy motifs based on the unforgettable theme music.
One afternoon, as I was plugging in The Twilight Zone pinball machine, I was surrounded by flashing spectral light like a strobe light. I stepped out of the corner, and it vanished. I stepped back into the corner, and I was surrounded by the light again.
When I finished my Happy Hour shift around 9:00 or 9:30, I loved to stick around, have a few beers, and use my tips to play the pinball machine. I always got lots of quarters in my tip jar. After playing a game, I could turn around and watch the young men on the dance floor.
I was setting out ashtrays in the empty bar before opening, and about halfway through the dance floor, I had to stop and turn back--I sensed something in the corner where there stood several large stacks of extra chairs. The rest of the afternoon I stayed put behind the bar, eyeing that corner of the bar. When the D.J. showed up for her shift a few hours later, she said to me: "Mr. Thing is back there in the corner," and I felt a chill because I knew it too.
I felt a presence walk up behind me as I prepared the till. I turned around and there was no one there.
I saw a white figure wave at me in my peripheral vision as I handed a customer a "greyhound" across the bar. It vanished when I turned my head.
On a dead weeknight in March, I lost the battle with my fear of the bar. A drunk, belligerent customer threatened to cut my throat. He had come from the strip club across the street, and I refused to serve him because he was already sloppy drunk. The second he walked out the door, I locked it behind him, afraid he might come back, even though it wasn't midnight yet.
Instead of calling the police, I just decided to close the bar. The only customer was my friend who had witnessed the whole thing. When the owner stopped in unexpectedly, I was still cleaning up. The owner immediately fired me for closing early.
Last August, when I visited my hometown of Fort Collins after being away for many years, it was a strange shock to discover that the old Nightingale's building had been completely demolished. In its place stood a bank.
Does Mr. Thing haunt the bank after hours?
I discovered that Tony died from AIDS a few years ago. I searched online to see if he had a Facebook page, and found his obituary instead.
It felt like Nightingale’s had become a ghost bar, along with all of its stories: the horrible fire long ago, the tragedy of Matthew Shepard, my lost love Tony, and the mysterious ghosts that haunted the dance floor where I came out of the closet and played The Twilight Zone pinball machine.
Was the ghost in my imagination? Was everyone feeding me stories because they could see I was afraid? The bar itself was dark and gothic enough to push anyone's imagination. Over the years, I speculated the ghost in the bar was just a projection of my own anxieties about being gay, a shadow figure of myself, but then I remembered how the D.J. and I both sensed something in the corner by the chairs.
With its flashing, disorienting lights--like the dance floor--and its pitfalls, twists, and turns, The Twilight Zone pinball machine embodied my experience at Nightingale’s. More than that, I felt like I was in The Twilight Zone, venturing into the strange and dangerous world of being gay.